Bob & Ann

Vinemont AL

Senior Member

Joined: 01/24/2002

View Profile


Good Sam RV Club Member
Offline
|
It is really a case of preference. We started with the tow dolly and used it for about a year. There were four things that we did not like about the dolly.
1. It was fine loading it on a sunny day. Rainy days were a problem trying to get the strap around the muddy tire. It was just a lot messier then hooking up a toad flat.
2. Storing the dolly at the house was not a major problem but it was taking up space.
3. Finding a place to store the dolly in tight campgrounds was as problem. I would try to push it under the front or real bumper but it was in the way.
4. In vacation resort areas the campgrounds wanted to charge a fee to park the dolly in their parking area.
We mainly found the towing flat option to be a faster, cleaner hook up. up.
Bob and Ann
One HAPPY Schnauzer - Della
One FRISKY Chihuahua - Lola
One FLUFFY 14 Year Old Cat - Frazier
2005 37 DB Allegro Bay
Workhorse Chassis
GM 8.1L (496 CID)
340 HP
Onan 7000 Watt
Double Slide
2006 Suzuki Grand Vitara Toad
|
willald

NC

Senior Member

Joined: 07/15/2002

View Profile

|
..Don't own the MH yet, but will soon. And we ARE planning to use a dolly, and probably will for at least several years.
I've researched this very thoroughly. The vehicle we need to bring with us, a Kia Sedona minivan, would cost something north of $3000 to set up for 4 down towing. A nice (new) Dolly can be had for less than HALF that much. And, we'd get to spend some of that $3k all over again, every time we trade vehicles. No thanks.
Really like the idea of being able to tow almost ANY FWD vehicle made. Also like that I can do so without having to alter or do ANYTHING to the towed vehicle at all.
I've watched several videos, researched tons, etc. on the differences in hookup procedures for dolly vs 4 down towing. No doubt 4 down towing is easier, and would be the way to go if you were full time and on the road all the time, or had health issues and bending down a lot was an issue. Still, I'm just not seeing where hitching up with a dolly can possibly be as bad as some make it out to be. Looks pretty simple and easy to me, no worse than what I'm used to with our current setup.
For a working stiff like me in their 40s and still plenty healthy enough to work a dolly (AAMOF my fat a** could use the exercise!), and still feeding several mouths and don't have an extract $3k to throw at a 4 down setup (or another $1k to throw at it every time towed vehicle is traded)......The dolly just makes a LOT more sense.
Now, when the van wears out and we have to replace it, THEN I may replace it with a vehicle that can be towed 4 down wihout so much expense/modification, and we may go to 4 down towing then. Until then, though, it just is not worth the expense for us.
This is another of those choices like a zillion other RV related things (DP vs gasser, MH vs towable RV, etc) - There is no one size fits all, everyone's situation is different, and the right choice is the one that fits YOUR budget, needs, and wants. Thats 'bout all there is to it.
Will & Angela
2 children that love camping, Stephen & Allison
2012 FR Georgetown 351DS on F53 (V10) Chassis ("No Taxpayers were harmed by the makers of this MH's chassis")
Our Rig
|
Hikerdogs

Wisconsin

Senior Member

Joined: 08/23/2004

View Profile

Offline
|
We used to tow our Buick LeSabre on a Roadmaster dolly. After several years of towing it along then parking it while we rented a Jeep we decided to just buy a Jeep and tow it with us 4 down. We still have the Jeep and enjoy the off road experience. However it is a rough ride and doesn't have all the conveniences of our Buick Lucerne.
We still have the dolly stored in the garage. At some point in time we may get tired of the Jeep and switch back to the cushy ride of the Buick. At that time we'll get the dolly out of the garage, dust it off, put on some new tires and take the Buick with us. I don't see it happening in the near future, but it doesn't cost anything to store the dolly and there's plenty of room.
Selling the dolly for 1/2 or less than we paid for it then buying another one for twice the price of the original a couple years in the future doesn't make much sense.
To me there isn't much difference in weight or effort to use the dolly. Both systems have their pros and cons. They're just different. As willald mentioned if you do the research and buy one that is designed so you don't have to crwawl through the mud and doesn't require a contortionist to load you can use it for many years without problems.
Hikerdogs
2001 Winnebago Adventurer
|
HEASON

Raleigh,NC

Full Member

Joined: 12/31/2002

View Profile


Good Sam RV Club Member
Offline
|
I have a 2009 Saturn vue and a Blue Ox hitch that work very well for me. There is one fuse to pull which I have replaced with a cut off switch that is simple to install. I have been towing a car since 2001, but have never used a tow dolly. I would be happy to answer any other questions regarding this matter.
PS: Blue ox has an excellent support group and are happy to answer any questions. They also have a nice campground for your use while they repair or service your hitch. They are located in Pender, Nebraska.
|
racer99

channahon

Senior Member

Joined: 02/16/2010

View Profile


Good Sam RV Club Member
Offline
|
we have a DEMCO tow dolly with surge brakes-we tow either the 2007 ford focus or the 2000 ford ranger-We have had no issues at any campground-we have figured out how to tighten the straps so they never come loose (although if I stop for potty I do check them) have never had straps loosen-If it rains either way 4 down or dolly your going to get wet-I have a raincoat and couple rubber mats to kneel on---NOW if your not getting around good and can't bend by all means spend the extra money and go 4 down-Main thing is your enjoying life-Rich
pauperspride.blogspot.com
1991 bounder/454 chevy/p30/31'
|
|
|
sailor_lou

Connecticut

Senior Member

Joined: 04/01/2006

View Profile


Good Sam RV Club Member
Offline
|
We recently sold our dolly, but used it for 6 years with no regrets. I purchased it used and sold it pretty close to our original purchase price. It's not quite as easy as four down, but with a FWD car it less wear and tear on the drivetrain and is no where as difficult as many try to make it out. The main reason we shifted over was because we are finally reducing our fleet of cars to one tow vehicle.
Lou
05 Travel Supreme Envoy
|
dieharder

Ottawa, ON

Senior Member

Joined: 09/10/2009

View Profile


Good Sam RV Club Member
Offline
|
willald wrote: ..Don't own the MH yet, but will soon. And we ARE planning to use a dolly, and probably will for at least several years.
I've researched this very thoroughly. The vehicle we need to bring with us, a Kia Sedona minivan, would cost something north of $3000 to set up for 4 down towing. A nice (new) Dolly can be had for less than HALF that much. And, we'd get to spend some of that $3k all over again, every time we trade vehicles. No thanks.
Really like the idea of being able to tow almost ANY FWD vehicle made. Also like that I can do so without having to alter or do ANYTHING to the towed vehicle at all.
I've watched several videos, researched tons, etc. on the differences in hookup procedures for dolly vs 4 down towing. No doubt 4 down towing is easier, and would be the way to go if you were full time and on the road all the time, or had health issues and bending down a lot was an issue. Still, I'm just not seeing where hitching up with a dolly can possibly be as bad as some make it out to be. Looks pretty simple and easy to me, no worse than what I'm used to with our current setup.
For a working stiff like me in their 40s and still plenty healthy enough to work a dolly (AAMOF my fat a** could use the exercise!), and still feeding several mouths and don't have an extract $3k to throw at a 4 down setup (or another $1k to throw at it every time towed vehicle is traded)......The dolly just makes a LOT more sense.
Now, when the van wears out and we have to replace it, THEN I may replace it with a vehicle that can be towed 4 down wihout so much expense/modification, and we may go to 4 down towing then. Until then, though, it just is not worth the expense for us.
This is another of those choices like a zillion other RV related things (DP vs gasser, MH vs towable RV, etc) - There is no one size fits all, everyone's situation is different, and the right choice is the one that fits YOUR budget, needs, and wants. Thats 'bout all there is to it. 
Just speaking from personal experience.
The first time I towed, I used a dolly to tow my Freestar (not much bigger then the Sedona) to Myrtle Beach. I got back home from that trip, and had pictures of the dolly still attached to the back of the motorhome on usedottawa.com before I had even unpacked and it was out of my life in 3 days. Will never use a dolly again. The weight of the dolly + the weight of the van was just too much back there.
Since then, I rented cars when we toured Florida last spring, and I now have an HHR which can be towed 4 down which we will be using from now on. I feel much more comfortable with that arrangement.
1999 Itasca Sunrise
|
sreyneke

Tennessee

New Member

Joined: 09/17/2011

View Profile


Good Sam RV Club Member
Offline
|
I use my RV on average about once a month for 2 to 3 days at a time, we use a tow dolly, and we take a car and 4 bicycles with every time. We have a number of cars in the family and none can be flat towed. We also don’t keep a car much longer than 3 years, so for us a tow dolly is the answer. If you are physically in good shape and can get down low to strap down the car, it is a good option to consider. I have noticed that my wife and I can load and unload the car in about the same time as some people who flat tow. It all depends on how much work you are willing to do loading, unloading and moving the dolly around. For now it is good exercise while we can do it.
|
LongWeekends

Scottsdale, AZ

Full Member

Joined: 09/07/2011

View Profile

Offline
|
My .02, A dolly gives you one more thing to store at home and on the road. Not a problem to some but we have too much "suff" as it is :-)
Truth be told, we had just assumed we could flat tow my wife's Acura MDX when we bought our RV. Turns out you can't. Not a HUGE deal. I have a car hauler for an old Porsche(my other hobby), we'll just throw the MDX on it. Oops! The trailer is 1", yes 1" too narrow. Shoot!
So now we flat tow my 2007 Suburban. SUPER easy and so glad we sort of got "forced" into it. We are hooked and unhooked in no time with nothing to store. I have used dollys in the past and there is no doubt in my mind that flat towing is quicker and easier.
Michael
Just me, my wife, our 11 year old daughter and our two big, hairy Goldens.
2004 Coachmen Cross Country
370DS - 300HP - 2 Slides
2007 Suburban(Not the best toad but hey, it works and has room for the dogs)
|
Maddawgs

central MA

Senior Member

Joined: 03/02/2010

View Profile


Offline
|
We tow with the Demco. My car is not 4 down tow-able and I could not see buying another car that was and then buying base plates, tow bars, and braking system. The Demco is easy to use, allows me to tow whatever I want, and folds to half it's size if needed.
Todd
Todd, Shirley, and the "Maddawgs" min-pins Precious and Buster Brown
2011 Itasca Cambria 30C
2011 Demco KarKaddy 460SS
TST 507 RV TPMS
"if there is anything left when we are gone, then we miscalculated"
|
|
|
|